Extra virgin, virgin or simply olive oil: the names on the label may sound similar, but what is in the bottle can differ considerably. Some oils come directly from olives; others contain refined oil. The diagram below shows at a glance what the different names mean.

The Categories at a Glance

The category depends on how the oil is produced and on the characteristics it must have by law.

Directly from olives

Mechanical or other physical methods, without refining

Extra virgin olive oil

Aroma and flavour
Fruitiness; no sensory defects
Free acidity
Maximum 0.8%

May be sold to consumers in the EU

Read the detailed explanation →

Virgin olive oil

Aroma and flavour
Fruitiness; limited sensory defects permitted
Free acidity
Maximum 2.0%

May be sold to consumers in the EU

Read the detailed explanation →

Ordinary virgin olive oil

Classification
IOC category; not an EU category
Aroma and flavour
More defects permitted than in virgin olive oil
Free acidity
Maximum 3.3%

Not a marketing category in the EU

Read the detailed explanation →

Lampante olive oil

Characteristics
Does not meet the requirements for edible virgin olive oil
Intended use
Refining or technical use

May not be sold to consumers as food in the EU

Read the detailed explanation →

After refining

Unwanted aromas, flavours and colour are largely removed, and free acidity is reduced

Lampante olive oil Refined olive oil Blending with virgin olive oil

Refined olive oil

Origin
Olive oil obtained directly from olives and then refined
Aroma and flavour
Almost neutral

May not be sold to consumers in the EU

Read the detailed explanation →

Olive oil composed of refined olive oils and virgin olive oils

Composition
Refined olive oil blended with virgin or extra virgin olive oil
Aroma and flavour
Usually mild

May be sold to consumers in the EU

Read the detailed explanation →

From the olive residue

Pomace remains after the olive oil has been separated from the water and solid matter

Pomace Extracting and refining the oil Blending with virgin olive oil

The sensory requirements listed are legal criteria for each category. They do not mean that every bottle has been assessed by an official tasting panel before sale. During official checks, an accredited panel may assess whether the aroma and flavour of virgin olive oil meet the legal requirements.

Smelling, Tasting and Measuring

Within the European Union, the requirements for extra virgin and virgin olive oil are laid down in law. The company placing the oil on the market is responsible for ensuring that it meets the requirements for the category stated on the label.”

Laboratory tests examine, among other things, free acidity, oxidation and ageing, the composition of the oil, and possible signs of refining or blending. These tests can also reveal irregularities or fraud, for example when the composition of the oil does not match the category stated on the label.

An accredited tasting panel may also be involved in official checks. Panel members assess the oil using an established method. They do not give a personal opinion about its taste. Instead, they assess fruitiness and possible defects, such as rancidity, or mustiness. They also assess positive attributes such as bitterness and pungency.

To meet the legal requirements for extra virgin olive oil, both its chemical and sensory characteristics must fall within the prescribed limits. Low free acidity alone is therefore not enough.

Categories of Virgin Olive Oil

Virgin olive oil is obtained directly from olives using only mechanical or other physical methods. It is not refined. Laboratory results and the tasting panel’s assessment determine which category the oil belongs to.

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

To qualify for this highest quality grade, the oil must meet all the specified chemical requirements. In the official sensory assessment, no defects may be detected, and fruitiness must be perceptible.

Free acidity may not exceed 0.8 grams per 100 grams. Olive oil consists mainly of triglycerides: fat molecules to which fatty acids are attached. When fatty acids are released from them, they are called free fatty acids. This can happen, for example, when olives are damaged or diseased, or are not handled and stored carefully.

Free acidity indicates how much of these free fatty acids is present in the oil. It is measured in a laboratory and expressed as grams of oleic acid per 100 grams of oil. You cannot smell or taste free acidity. The value therefore does not mean that the oil smells or tastes sour.

The official English designation used in EU legislation is “extra virgin olive oil”.

The Dutch legal designation contains a word meaning “pressing”, but the oil does not have to be made with a traditional or modern press. Modern olive mills usually use centrifuges.

Virgin Olive Oil

The difference from extra virgin olive oil lies in the quality assessment. Virgin olive oil may have limited sensory defects. Its free acidity may also be higher: up to 2.0 grams per 100 grams, compared with a maximum of 0.8 grams for extra virgin olive oil.

Virgin olive oil may be sold directly as food, but it does not belong to the highest quality grade.

Ordinary Virgin Olive Oil

The International Olive Council (IOC) also includes ordinary virgin olive oil in its international classification.

The oil is obtained directly from olives and is not refined. More sensory defects are permitted than in virgin olive oil. Free acidity may also be higher: up to 3.3 grams per 100 grams, compared with a maximum of 2.0 grams for virgin olive oil.

In countries where this is permitted, the oil may be sold directly to consumers as ordinary virgin olive oil. This category does not exist in the European Union. Oil that fails to meet the EU requirements for extra virgin or virgin olive oil may not be sold directly to consumers under those designations.

Lampante Olive Oil

Like extra virgin and virgin olive oil, lampante olive oil is obtained directly from olives and is not refined. The name lampante refers to its former use as fuel in oil lamps.

A trained tasting panel assesses the aroma and flavour of the oil. If the panel detects no fruitiness or finds clear sensory defects, the oil may fall into the lampante category.

The laboratory also tests its chemical characteristics. If they do not meet the requirements for virgin olive oil, that too may lead to classification as lampante. An oil is therefore not automatically lampante simply because it tastes mild or has little pronounced flavour.

Damaged or diseased olives can cause a loss of quality. Quality can also deteriorate during transport, processing or storage. However, this does not automatically make the oil lampante.

Lampante olive oil may not be sold directly to consumers as food. It can be refined and then used as an ingredient in another category of olive oil.

Refined Olive Oil

Refining is not a single treatment but an industrial process consisting of several steps.

Refineries first reduce the amount of free fatty acids in the oil. They then add materials that bind pigments, oxidation products and other unwanted substances. These materials are subsequently filtered out. Finally, steam, a strong vacuum and a high temperature remove substances that cause unwanted aromas and flavours.

The result of these treatments is refined olive oil. It has little aroma, flavour or colour of its own and is no longer virgin olive oil.

Olive Oil Composed of Refined Olive Oils and Virgin Olive Oils

On the front of a bottle, the words “olive oil” may stand out most. But the full legal designation must also appear in the principal field of vision: “olive oil composed of refined olive oils and virgin olive oils”.

This product is a blend of refined olive oil and oil obtained directly from olives. In the European Union, that second component may be either virgin or extra virgin olive oil.

The refined oil is almost neutral in aroma and flavour. The added virgin or extra virgin olive oil gives the blend some aroma, flavour and colour.

EU rules specify which types of oil the product may contain, but do not prescribe a fixed blending ratio that applies to all products. The proportions may therefore vary from one product to another.

This oil is sold in supermarkets and can also be used in food service.

Oil from Olive Pomace

During milling, whole olives are crushed into olive paste. During extraction, the oil is then separated from the water and solid matter. What remains is therefore not olive paste, but a moist residue of pulp, skins, pieces of stone, water and a small amount of oil. This residue is called pomace; in Dutch it is also known as sansa.

More oil can be extracted from the pomace in a separate industrial process, which may use solvents or other physical treatments. The resulting crude oil is not suitable for direct consumption. If it is to be used as food, it must therefore first be refined.

For the consumer product, the refined oil is blended with virgin olive oil that is fit for consumption. The official English sales designation under EU law is “olive-pomace oil”. The word “pomace” refers to the olive residue. It does not mean that the olives are pressed a second time.

The name sansa oil is also used in Dutch. Olive-pomace oil belongs to a separate legal category and is not the same as virgin or extra virgin olive oil.

What Does the Label Tell You?

Olive oil is a general term for products that differ in how they are obtained, processed and classified. To find out what is in a bottle, look for the full legal designation on the label.

More about choosing and storing olive oil →


Sources